How Little Momentum Shifts Spell Big Trouble For Eagles

Games can turn on one or two moments; a call here, a mistake there, and momentum shifts—that’s certainly what happened in the USA vs Argentina XV game, and every moment seemed to turn the game in favor of the hosts.

USA mistakes and skill breakdowns, and one or two dodgy calls, combined with some clinical finishing from Argentina XV, put the USA 21-0 at halftime with a player off with a red card. 

The Eagles never recovered. And they could have. 

Defensive Mismatches And Mistakes 

There’s no way around it, the USA gifted Argentina XV this opening try. The movement started after Argentina regained the ball after a box kick. What became quickly apparent was that the USA wider defensive line consisted of mostly forwards. Prop Titi Lamositele, lock Greg Peterson, and lock Nick Civetta were guarding the Argentina backs.

The ball was sent quickly out to the wing. Civetta took it upon himself to nip that movement in the bud by blitzing up. He was too late, or Argentina was too quick (kind of the same thing), and that left a big hole with only Bryce Campbell and Gannon Moore to cover.

Moore has Dominguez dead to rights and could have thumped the Argentinian wing into touch. But he went a little too high, and thought more about collision and less about wrapping up. Dominguez swatted him aside.

Next up Campbell—he’s just not fast enough, and probably should have just shadowed the Argentina support runners. That left AJ MacGinty, who had stayed back as a fullback. MacGinty, normally a good tackler, puts in a poor effort—one that says “I just got off shoulder surgery.”

He does slow Dominguez enough that Will Magie and Shaun Davies can get there. One more mistake. Magie goes way to high, but not aggressively enough to tie up the ball, and Davies makes a tackle, only for Dominguez to offload beautifully to Carreras for the try.

Not enough communication on defense to adjust the alignment; three players going for the big hit now instead of containment; poor tackling technique.

Watch USA vs Argentina XV On-Demand

Second Try

The actual try scored by Argentina XV was a thing of beauty. They identified a hole in the USA defense in the lineout and exploited it. The play of the movement was from the scrumhalf, Alejandro Experra, who took a pass and immediately changed director to set up Favre. Brilliant stuff.

But it never should have happened. The lineout came from a penalty unfairly called on the USA.

The teams were setting up for a scrum, which had to be reset.

Referee Gonzalez then had a chat with Lamositele, and it’s clear Lamositele is saying Argentina is binding around his armpit and dragging him down.


On the next engagement, not only is Lamositele proved right, Argentina prop Lucas Favre actually changes his bind during the scrum, from further down Lamositele’s back to his armpit. That’s a no-no—easily a penalty. Gonzales, who is right there, calls a penalty against the USA.

Bad call from the referee, compounded by excellent play from Argentina XV

Chance Gone

After the first two tries, the USA had the run of play. Several times they had good scoring opportunities.

Here’s one. Some excellent work stemming from a turnover produced by the USA defense. The offloads and strength in contact are there, and the USA has a chance. Watch this from Joe Taufete’e.


He’s hit, but he looks for support. Why do we point that out? Because closer to the tryline, he’s in the same position, and instead crawls ahead trying to score, giving up the ball. 

This was an enormous play, because a try at this point would have made it 14-7 and the Eagles are still in it.

There's more. Knock-ons, kicks when they weren't needed ... the chickens noticed in Chile and against Samoa came home to roost.

Frustration Sets In

But they’re not in it, and the frustration grows. Here, Argentina is clearly offside (Favre again) and Hanco Germishuys complains to no avail.

So when Paul Lasike is grabbed around the ankle and impeded, who lashes out, and gets a red card.

Moments later, Argentina XV scores another try. The USA players think the final pass is forward. It might have been—it was a very flat pass to a speedy, onrushing teammate. But it’s not called.

More important to this analysis is Dino Waldren’s expression.


That is the expression of a team that is seeing the game slip away. 

Change one or two of these things. Get the call in the scrum, or make the first tackle in the opening minute. Or … curl back away from the tryline and let the support come in and go at it again, or fall to the ground when a player grabs your ankle and get the penalty called for you, not against you.

From those little moments momentum changes come.

Air Force Women Are Back-to-Back Champs

In what might have been the hardest-hitting game of the weekend, Air Force held off a determined Navy team to win their second straight national title. 

Redemption & National Title For Winona State

Winona State fought through two extremely tough games to become the 2019 DII National Champions. 

Queens Dominate To Win National Title

Queens were simply ruthless over the weekend, as they put in two dominant displays en route to winning their first ever national championship just two-and-a-half years into their existence. 

Men's DII Collegiate Semifinal Preview

The men's DII collegiate field will be trimmed from its last four teams to its last two on Saturday, when Wisconsin-Whitewater, Missouri S&T, Norwich University, and Queens University compete in the DII semifinals. 

DIAA National Championship Preview

null

So different, yet so alike are Western Michigan and Iowa Central Community College. 

Women's DII Collegiate Semifinal Preview

Four teams remain standing in Women's DII rugby this fall, and by Sunday afternoon there will be just one. 

Schedule: USAR Fall College Championships

This weekend we reach the conclusion of what's been a highly competitive fall campaign of rugby across four divisions - Men's DIAA, Women's DI, and Men's and Women's DII. 

Upright Rouge Women Bring NY Collegiate 7s Title Back To Canada

An incredible late comeback in the final from the Upright Rugby Rouges led the girls to a championship in the Collegiate bracket at this weekend's New York 7s. 

NYAC Boys Dominate NY Collegiate 7s

Nobody was more dominant at the New York 7s this past weekend than the NYAC collegiate side. 

Lions Academy: 2019 NY 7s Men's Premier Champs

The Lions Academy fought off two huge comeback efforts in the semifinals and finals of the New York 7s to take home the Men's Premier Cup championship.