Who Will Make It? D1A Speculations

On The Sidelines With Cal

This weekend sees the first conference game of the winter-spring D1A season, and, as usual, thoughts turn to who might win.

So unfair, isn’t it, to say who will win before everyone plays. But, hey, that’s the cruelty of sports. D1A will once again make some fall teams wait for the rankings in late March to confirm who gets in, and who doesn’t. We’ll jump the gun a little, and give you the list of who’s in right now, and who’s not.

Conference Champs:

Liberty - Iona. This is a weird one in the sense that there was no playoff, but Iona was better than Syracuse or AIC and those were the two next-best teams. 

Rugby East - Army

Big Ten - Wisconsin

Rocky Mountain - BYU

Wisconsin Looking For A Big 10 Title

Who makes the playoffs? Army and Wisconsin are for sure in. There’s little doubt that Penn State will be ranked highly enough to get in. Iona doesn’t plan to attend, and in fact no one from the Liberty will. Colorado State is probably the second-best Rocky Mountain team, but will have a tough time getting that coveted ranking. It’s possible some other Rugby East teams might get a look, if they want it.

Conferences In Progress:

Red River

Arkansas, Oklahoma, and Texas A&M are all looking pretty good. Right now, we’re picking A&M due to a stronger defense.

Can Anyone Else Make the Playoffs? 

No. A Red River team probably needs to win a playoff game for that to happen.


This has barely started, but it’s already clear that it could be a four-team race, but we're picking Life University (yeah, I know, we went out on a limb).

But … Lindenwood especially, and also Navy or Arkansas State, could sneak in.

Can Anyone Else Make the Playoffs? 

We could see all six teams, to be honest. Probably Life, Lindenwood, Arkansas State, and Navy. Davenport has an outside shot, and Clemson a really outside shot.

Conferences Starting


Who will win? Seriously? Cal.

Can Anyone Else Make the Playoffs? 

Arizona. Feel pretty confident about that. Jury’s out on the other three. The winner of Utah v UCLA on Feb 9 will have a better shot, and that team will have to perform well in key games afterward (for UCLA that’s March 16 vs San Diego State and for Utah that would be Utah State on March 9).


Who Will Win: Saint Mary’s


Can Anyone Else Make the Playoffs? 

There’s a really nice chase for a playoff spot among several teams in this conference. Somebody deserves to, we just don’t know who it is. Cal Poly? Yeah, sure. SD SU? Maybe. Grand Canyon is new to the conference and could be the one.


The pecking order is pretty straightforward among these teams. Notre Dame is not as strong as Iona or Davenport, so if they’re not ranked highly enough, neither should Notre Dame be. 

Central Washington beat UC Davis, which is a good start. A loss to Saint Mary’s isn’t the end of their run. The key will be to beat teams like Utah State, Cal Poly, Colorado State, and Grand Canyon.

And … Utah Valley. Another independent team. They need to beat Central Washington to make it.

The Bracket

How does that leave our speculative bracket?

(We’d put Ohio State in here if we thought they’d want to go)

1. Life vs 16. Utah Valley or possibly UCLA

8. Navy vs 9. Arizona 

4. BYU vs 13. Grand Canyon or SDSU or Cal Poly

5. Army vs 12. Arkansas State

2. Cal vs 15. Central Washington

7. Penn State vs 10. Utah

3. Saint Mary’s vs 14. Someone from the Red River

6. Lindenwood vs 11. St. Bonaventure or Grand Canyon or SDSU or Cal Poly

D1AA Playoff Picture Latest

Here’s where we are on D1AA playoff picture after an interesting run of results this week.

No One Has Lost More Games, But He's An All-Time Great Nonetheless

Italy rugby great Sergio Parisse bid farewell to the Stadio Olimpico in Rome this weekend with another bitter disappointment as the Azzurri snatched a 25-14 defeat from the jaws of victory against France.

Toulouse Still Atop French Top 14

France international Sofiane Guitoune scored a hattrick as Toulouse thrashed Lyon 53-21 to extend their advantage at the top of the French Top 14 on Sunday.

Glendale Surprise Leads PRP Results

The Glendale Merlins pulled off a bit of an upset this weekend in the Pacific Rugby Premiership, defeating the Santa Monica Dolphins 43-37 to move up in the standings to 4th.

Rankings Ramifications: D1A Weekend Wrapup

New USA Callup Duncan Van Schalkwyk

The strong stay strong in Men's D1A College action with six games played this weekend.

Wales Shuts Down Ireland To Win Grand Slam

Wales claimed a record third Six Nations Grand Slam during coach Warren Gatland's reign Saturday as Gareth Anscombe kicked 20 points to help beat an ill-disciplined Ireland 25-7.

Chico State Scare Stirs Up D1AA Playoff Picture

While the spring conferences in D1AA are coming down to the wire, there's the potential for a shakeup in at least one competition.

Samurai PRP Player Of The Week: Adam Channel, Belmont Shore

Adam Channel Scores Five For Belmont Shore

In 2018, Belmont Shore was crowned PRP champion, but after a long playoff run they were left heartbroken in the national championship final.

Barbarians To Face USA Women In Glendale

Women Eagles Hard At Work

The USA Women's team will play a historic game April 26 when they face the Barbarians FC in Glendale, CO.

D1A Playoff Thoughts On Crucial Weekend

On The Sidelines With Cal

We are coming to a very crucial time in D1A rugby as the playoffs are not far.