2018 Americas Pacific Challenge

Eagle Men Depth Chart: The Front Row

Eagle Men Depth Chart: The Front Row

We look at who is on the long list for a World Cup spot.

Sep 27, 2018 by Alex Goff
Joe Taufete'e Gets A Kiss From The Coach

With the naming of the Americas Pacific Challenge roster for the USA Selects, we're getting an idea of what the Eagles overall depth chart might look like.

Watch All Nine Americas Pacific Challenge Games LIVE on FloRugby
Round 1 October 6
Round 2 October 10
Round 3 October 14

The chart has to be big, because the USA often has to field a squad without some of the overseas pros being released. This might be because a game is outside of the official World Rugby test match window, or because players have to hand rest periods, or because a club might be recalcitrant.

And then competitions like the APC aren't full test competitions, so pros don't have to be released.

With all of that in mind, we've got a potential depth chart of over 60 players. It's designed to give you fans an idea of who is out there now. Here's our front row, and our comments:

Prop


Paul MullenNewcastle Falcons (Gallagher Premiership)
Eric FryVannes (France Pro D2)
Chris BaumannUnattached
Titi LamositeleSaracens (Gallagher Premiership)
Olive KilifiSeattle Seawolves (MLR)
Chance WenglewskiLindenwood University
Angus MacLellanUtah Warriors (MLR)
David AinuuToulouse Academy (French Top 14)
Dino WaldrenLond Scottish
Kelepi FifitaGlendale Raptors (MLR)
Tony PurpuraOld Blue
John HaydenSeattle Seawolves (MLR)
Huluholo MoungaloaLife West (PRP)


The prop position needs a few more bodies in there, as it's a position under a ton of physical stress. In addition, notice that five of these players are with overseas pro clubs. 


Rugby Nomad Finds Home At Leicester


To this list we might look at Patrick Ryan of Austin Elite who was perhaps expected too quickly to perform at a test level. He didn't get a lot of positive press from these pages in 2017, but some time to regroup might make him an Eagle again.

We don't have Alex Maughan here because he was listed for the APC as a hooker, but he certainly can be a prop for the USA.

Of these players, Hayden, Kilifi, Fifita, and Wenglewski (as well as Maughan) are in the APC. Least known might be Hayden, who emerged as a force for Seattle, and played with the Fallbrook HS program 13 years ago and was a HS All American before enrolling at Central Washington.

Fifita is two years younger than the 25-year-old Hayden, and hasn't played as long, but he's a solid athlete and mobile.

It will be interesting to see how Moungaloa battles for a spot as he has not been an MLR player, but the Pacific Rugby Premiership has a lot to offer in terms of high-level player development.

Hooker


Joe Taufete'eWorcester Warriors (Gallagher Premiership)
Dylan FawsittGlendale Raptors
James HilterbrandManly Marlins (Australia)
Alex MaughanLife University (Graduated)
Cam FalconNOLA Gold (MLR)
Pat O'TooleSan Diego Legion (MLR)


It's an intriguing move for the Eagles brain trust to slot Maughan in here, but when you consider that Hayden, Fifta, Chance Wenglewski are over six feet tall and north of 260 pounds, and that Maughan is smaller than that, it makes sense. Maughan is an excellent leader and scrummager, and it might be that hooker is the place for him.

Maughan, Falcon, and O'Toole are the APC players, and it's clear Gary Gold needs some depth here. He was down to one hooker when the USA played Canada in June, with flanker Hanco Germishuys probably his backup in that game.

Not listed here is Peter Malcolm, who captained the USA Selects in the APC in 2017. Malcolm is recovering from knee surgery and should be able to play in 2019. If he gets back to full fitness, he's definitely high in this list. There's been some thought that players such as Germyshuys, Vili Toluta'u, or Pat Blair should track to a #2 jersey, but that might negate some of the other things those players bring to the table.

If anyone's asking FloRugby, we'd say keep those guys as flankers.