Are Challenge Matches A Better Format For College Postseason?


By John Broker

I am going to throw out an opinion about the college rugby postseason that I am not sure I agree with, and we can discuss from there, as rugby people are wont to do.

The Liberty Conference Challenge takes place at Fairfield University in Fairfield, CT, this Saturday, with a great slate of games for teams across the Northeast. It is a one-day event and includes Delaware, Tufts, UMASS, Stony Brook, Albany, Fairfield, Syracuse, URI, Binghamton, UCONN, AIC, Fordham, Northeastern, and Cortland.

Watch the 2017 Liberty Conference Challenge LIVE on FloRugby

In other parts of the country, teams will be traveling greater distances to play two games in two days to move on in national championship rounds. 

The question is the role of national championships in the evolving college rugby landscape. Could the resources be better used elsewhere if the burden on the players, teams, and schools were lessened for travel to nationals? Could concepts similar to the Challenge games provide equal competition at a better price and possibly still lead to a national champion? 

Pride And Resources

Nationals is a pride thing, and I have been involved in runs for nationals at a number of levels and in a number of roles, so I get it. But boy does it take some cash. A typical men’s college team in the Northeast usually has 3-4 away games each fall season, averaging 3-5 hours of travel, followed by a two-day weekend playoff and a play-in game that can be anywhere up to eight hours travel. The teams then travels to Pennsylvania for a two-game weekend and, depending on outcome, heads to South Carolina for a two-game championship weekend. While it’s fun, it’s not easy and school support varies wildly throughout the country. 

There are of course a lot of variables in the conference setup nationwide, and I don’t envy the folks who have to make sense of it. But could a simpler setup leave for resources for player, coach, and program development? Would a reduced travel burden on teams and the fostering of conference rivalries benefit programs? Could the Liberty Conference Challenge serve as a starting point?

"Could a simpler setup leave for resources for player, coach and program development?"

Like I said at the start, I am not sure if I agree, but it is food for thought and definitely fodder for conversation. I loved all my involvement with nationals (and would love more), but change can sometimes be good.

We would love to hear what you all think, so go to the FloRugby Facebook and Twitter pages to join the conversation. 

Oh, and tune into on Saturday for the Liberty Challenge matches.

- John Broker is a longtime rugby coach and announcer who has covered some of the highest profile games in the USA. He most recently was the play-by-play announcer for the Saracens v USA Islanders game, and will be on-air this weekend for the Liberty Challenge matches.

A&M Holds Off Texas To Win Red River South

Alex Goff TAMU Team 2018.jpg Hood And Brown Break Down Texas A&M Victory

Texas A&M clinched the Red River South with a difficult 19-5 victory over a tenacious University of Texas team.

Much At Stake In Army-Navy Game

Colleen McCloskey Navy-Army-2016-McCloskey-1219.jpg

Army plays Navy this Saturday in Annapolis, Maryland, in a rivalry game to beat all rivalry games, and there’s even more than bragging rights at stake.

Three Questions For PRP To Answer This Weekend

Brian Jackson Belmont Shore v OMBAC Brian Jackson.jpg OMBAC Shows Patience To Get Tuisamoa His Hat Trick

Round six of the Pacific Rugby Premiership is here, and there are three midseason questions to ask ahead of Saturday's games.

Major College Games & Our Picks: Still Work To Do For Bubble Teams

Colleen McCloskey Navy_Dartmouth-1309.jpg Life's Alex Maughan Looks Ahead To Rematch With Lindenwood

How much, really, is at stake this weekend?

Samurai PRP Player Of The Week: Devereaux Ferris, Life West

Devereaux Ferris PRP POM March 17.jpg Life West Scores The Gamewinner

There's something to be said about sparking a comeback.

Beating Army #1 Goal As McNerney Leads Navy

Colleen McCloskey Navy_AirForce-1046.jpg

The answer is the same after every Navy game. Ask any opposing coach which Midshipmen player gave his team the most trouble and he will reply: "Their No. 8, their 18, that guy, Connor McNerney."

USA U18 Boys Qualify For Youth Olympics After All

Colleen McCloskey 2018 Youth Olmypic Qualifier Colleen McCloskey 1406.jpg Junior Waqavesi Talks Youth Olympics Qualifier

The USA Boys U18 sevens team has received a berth to the Youth Olympic Games this fall thanks to the successful qualification of Canada's boys field hockey squad.

College Playoffs: Confidence Picks

David Barpal ConfidencePicks1.jpg

We could say things are heating up in college rugby, but they are actually closer to a boiling point. It's now time to make some major predictions for both the D1A and D1AA playoffs.

It's All On The Line As A&M Hosts UT Live On FloRugby

Texas A-M March 2018 4.jpg

The title race implications are very straightforward on Saturday: If Texas A&M beats Texas at home, then the Aggies are in the Red River Conference final.

FloRugby's Midseason PRP All-Star Team

Brian Jackson photo Belmont Shore v Santa Monica Brian Jackson 2018 7.jpg PRP Top Plays Round 4

The Pacific Rugby Premiership is halfway through its season, and it's time to pick a midseason all-star team.