SANZAAR

South African Rugby News Recap: Etzebeth Says His Red Card Was 'A Mistake'

South African Rugby News Recap: Etzebeth Says His Red Card Was 'A Mistake'

South African rugby dominates the week, as Eben Etzebeth addresses his ban, URC sides make moves and rising stars such as Sacha Feinberg Mngomezulu shine.

Dec 11, 2025 by Philip Bendon
South African Rugby News Recap: Etzebeth Says His Red Card Was 'A Mistake'

South African rugby rarely produces a quiet week. This one has been particularly charged, blending controversy at test level with confirmation of its deep structural strength and a fierce domestic front as the URC and Champions Cup campaigns reach full throttle.

At the center of the global conversation is Eben Etzebeth. 

The double World Cup-winning lock broke his silence after receiving a 12-week suspension for making contact with the eye of Wales backrow Alex Mann during the Springboks record win in Cardiff. 

Etzebeth, who has played 141 tests without a previous red card, accepted the guilty verdict and issued a public apology that attempted to give context without excusing the act.

He described the incident as a mistake. He said he was reacting to an open-hand strike from Mann and insisted that the contact with the eye area happened as bodies collided and angles shifted. 

He emphasized that there was no intention to gouge and posted a video breakdown alongside his explanation. 

He said he owed young fans clarity because he did not want his own error to be interpreted as acceptable behavior. The independent panel ruled the action intentional and applied a mid-range sanction, before mitigation reduced the punishment to 12 weeks.

While the Welsh Rugby Union and World Rugby declined to comment on Etzebeth’s statement, the incident has reignited long standing debates around foul play, intent and slow-motion interpretation. 

Etzebeth said he hoped the added detail would give people perspective, though he stressed that he accepts responsibility. His words will not change the suspension, but the episode underlines the scrutiny the Springboks operate under and the personal standards they claim to uphold.

Away from the controversy, the architecture of South African rugby continues to impress. 

Dave Wessels, SA Rugby’s General Manager for High Performance, offered a candid look this week at how Rassie Erasmus has shaped the national system. 

Since taking charge in 2018, Erasmus has guided the Springboks to two Rugby World Cup titles and Rugby Championship victories in consecutive years. Wessels said the groundwork Erasmus laid in the Elite Player Development pathway, combined with his ability to refresh the senior squad without losing cohesion, has created a golden era.

Wessels now oversees the other national teams, and his first full cycle in the role has produced significant results. 

The Junior Boks ended a long wait by winning the 2025 World Rugby Under 20 Championship. The Blitzboks secured the HSBC SVNS World Championship and defended their Cape Town title. The Springbok women reached the quarterfinals of their Rugby World Cup for the first time. 

Wessels credited outstanding schools and club systems for the depth of talent and praised coaches Kevin Foote, Philip Snyman and Swys de Bruin for turning that talent into performance.

He singled out the rapid growth of the women’s game as an area of huge excitement. He said the commercial appetite for women’s rugby is growing and believes South Africa can become a genuine medal contender at the next World Cup. He repeatedly emphasized that much of this upward trajectory stems from the high standards set within the Springboks environment. He said Erasmus created clarity, purpose and a culture other teams now emulate.

That winning culture is driving competition and player ambition across the URC franchises. 

The Sharks are dealing with the possibility of losing Grant Williams, who is weighing lucrative overseas offers ahead of the expiration of his contract in mid 2026. The Springboks scrumhalf has been a key figure in Durban for almost a decade and remains a major attacking weapon for the national team. With the South African selection policy open to overseas-based players, and the financial power of Japanese and French clubs unmatched, the Sharks may struggle to retain him.

Meanwhile, the Lions confirmed another major retention success, tying scrumhalf Morne van den Berg to Johannesburg until at least 2028. He joins Ruan Venter and Quan Horn in committing their futures to the franchise. Van den Berg has passed the 100 appearance mark and remains a central figure in a squad building gradually and deliberately.

At Loftus, the Bulls are managing a fine balancing act between URC responsibilities and Springbok workload protocols. 

Handre Pollard, Wilco Louw, Ruan Nortje, Marco van Staden and Canan Moodie will sit out the Champions Cup trip to Northampton due to mandatory rest. Johan Ackermann still travels with nine internationals and welcomed the arrival of fly-half Kade Wolhuter, while Elrigh Louw continues his comeback, and Nizaam Carr returns as well. 

The Bulls have been consistent at altitude but still are hunting a defining win abroad.

The Stormers face an altogether different test, as they prepare for La Rochelle in Gqeberha in one of the standout fixtures of the round. 

The return of Sacha Feinberg Mngomezulu at fly-half is a significant boost. The young playmaker has become the face of a new generation, and his comeback arrives at the perfect moment. John Dobson fields nine Springboks in a lineup that signals clear ambition. Warrick Gelant returns at fullback, Evan Roos starts in a dynamic loose trio and Salmaan Moerat anchors the pack.

La Rochelle captain Gregory Alldritt described the South African trip as an energy drain, but also an opportunity. He said his side must play with freedom and intensity if they are to trouble an unbeaten Stormers team in familiar conditions. 

The French club has traveled with several young players who are experiencing South Africa for the first time. Alldritt said that sense of adventure could spark something unexpected.

Not all Stormers news was positive. 

Lock Adre Smith received a one-match suspension for stamping during the win over Bayonne. The disciplinary committee upheld the red card but judged the offense at the lower end of the sanction scale, before mitigation reduced it to one match.

At national level, Jerry Flannery added to the chorus of praise for Erasmus. 

The Springboks assistant coach called him a visionary and said the environment he has built is unlike anything he has seen. Flannery said Erasmus empowers his staff, creates unity and has elevated the level of South African rugby as a whole. He also warned rivals that South Africa remains the most physically dominant team in the game.

Amid this backdrop, Sacha Feinberg Mngomezulu capped a superb year by being named SA Players Player of the Year. He has reshaped the fly-half role and set scoring records, while becoming a central figure in the Springboks back line. 

Ox Nche, Malcolm Marx, Pieter Steph du Toit and Damian Willemse also were nominated. Donavan Don and Byrhandre Dolf took the sevens and women’s awards.

If this week revealed anything, it is the breadth of South African rugby’s influence. From the URC battlegrounds to the national platforms, from controversy to celebration, the game remains a force that commands attention and continues to evolve at pace.

How To Watch Investec Champions Cup Round 2 

All Investec Champions Cup and EPCR Challenge Cup matches will stream on FloRugby and the FloSports app in the United States.

Friday, Dec. 12

Saturday, Dec. 13

Sunday, Dec. 14

FloRugby and FloSports also are the U.S. home to:

Join The Rugby Conversation On FloRugby Social