All Blacks Player Ratings vs. England: Grand Slam Slips Away For Kiwis
All Blacks Player Ratings vs. England: Grand Slam Slips Away For Kiwis
All Blacks player ratings vs England after their 33-19 defeat at Twickenham. Identifying top performers, key issues and why New Zealand fell away late.
New Zealand walked into Twickenham knowing this fixture would reveal exactly where the All Blacks stand in the global pecking order.
Instead of taking a step forward, they delivered another uneven, frustrating performance that continues a pattern that has followed them all season.
For 20 minutes, they looked sharp, explosive and connected, stretching England with clean width and winning collisions through Peter Lakai, Leicester Fainga’anuku and Will Jordan.
But once the initial burst faded, so too did their accuracy.
- Subscribe To FloRugby To Watch Top 14, URC, and PREM Rugby All Season Long
- Springboks Rugby Reigns, 14-Man SA Beat France 32-17 In Paris Showdown
- Argentina Hits 50 In Cardiff To Spoil Tandy's Wales Debut In Autumn Opener
- The 100 Best Rugby Players In The World: The Full List
England adjusted. New Zealand did not.
The All Blacks dominated the wide channels early, yet repeatedly switched off defensively, conceded soft meters around the fringes and were punished in the air and in broken play.
Beauden Barrett endured one of the poorest outings of his test career with his kicking, positioning and decision-making all unraveling under pressure.
Cam Roigard and Quinn Tupaea produced moments of quality, but not enough to reset a side that drifted badly in key passages.
The biggest concern is not talent. It is consistency.
New Zealand flashed plenty of it in isolated bursts but never held control.
The pack offered effort but lacked the accuracy and authority required to match England’s physicality once the tide turned.
The New Zealand bench impact was minimal, the team's discipline wavered and the game management could not steady the ship when England seized momentum through George Ford’s tactical masterclass.
There were standouts, most notably Lakai and Fainga’anuku, who played with genuine purpose, but too many All Blacks sat between anonymous and overwhelmed.
The result was a fair reflection of a team still searching for cohesion, clarity and the ability to stay connected for the full 80.
England simply was hungrier, sharper and smarter in the moments that defined the match.
New Zealand cannot keep relying on talent alone. At this level, moments of brilliance are not enough.
The All Blacks need sustained control, structure and leadership, none of which emerged in a 33-19 defeat that leaves more questions than answers.
Here is how the All Blacks players fared at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham:
1 Ethan de Groot – 6
There were promising early scrummaging moments, but they faded as England adjusted.
De Groot struggled to provide consistent physicality around the park.
New Zealand needed more presence from the loosehead.
2 Codie Taylor – 7
Taylor was one of the All Blacks’ steadier contributors.
His carrying had real bite, he defended willingly and he took his try well.
Even so, he could not alter the overall trajectory of the match.
3 Fletcher Newell – 6
A mixed outing from the tighthead.
Newell was steady technically, but he could not disrupt England’s set-piece.
Around the field, he appeared quiet and failed to influence the game’s rhythm.
4 Scott Barrett – 6
There were good defensive moments, but they were offset by costly lapses.
Barrett struggled to impose himself on England’s carriers and lacked his usual intensity.
A frustrating night for a key forward.
5 Josh Lord – 7.5
A bright spot in an inconsistent pack.
Lord won the key line-out ball, defended intelligently and put himself about throughout.
His composure stood out when others faltered.
6 Simon Parker – 6
A solid shift without being a standout.
Parker tackled willingly and carried with purpose, but England’s second-half intensity limited his influence. Still, he showed glimpses of promise.
7 Ardie Savea – 7
Savea brought his usual work rate and competitiveness.
He carried hard, made important defensive plays and tried to lift his side when the game tilted. The problem is that he had too little support around him.
8 Peter Lakai – 8.5
A huge performance from the young No.8.
Lakai matched Ben Earl’s 20 carries and repeatedly dented England’s line with his athletic power.
One of the few All Blacks who genuinely troubled England throughout.
9 Cam Roigard – 6.5
Threatening early, but less assured as England tightened its defense.
Roigard’s kicking varied in accuracy, and his tempo control drifted.
A night of clear talent but inconsistent execution.
10 Beauden Barrett – 4
This will go down as one of Barrett’s most difficult tests.
His line kicking repeatedly put New Zealand under pressure, and his defensive positioning was exposed multiple times.
Decision-making lacked the clarity expected at this level.
11 Leicester Fainga’anuku – 8.5
By far New Zealand’s most effective back.
Fainga’anuku carried with real venom, broke tackles and forced England to adjust its defensive shape.
He deserved more ball than he received.
12 Quinn Tupaea – 7
A strong, direct presence in midfield.
Tupaea carried effectively and defended robustly.
He performed well, but lacked the support structure to turn his involvement into momentum.
13 Billy Proctor – 6
Proctor’s defensive work rate was high, but he struggled offensively.
England’s midfield pairing outshone him decisively.
A performance that will frustrate him.
14 Leroy Carter – 7.5
Carter looked dangerous when given space and made two decisive line breaks, one of which had a lovely chip and regather.
His footwork and sharp movement caused England problems before the reshuffle.
His involvement dropped as England took control.
15 Will Jordan – 7.5
Jordan remained a threat in broken play and made valuable meters.
His ability to create something from nothing was evident, as always.
However, England’s second-half spacing squeezed his influence significantly.
Replacements
16 Samisoni Taukei’aho – 5
Taukei’aho struggled to make a positive dent in the contest.
Errors and penalties disrupted New Zealand’s attempts to claw its way back.
A disappointing outing.
17 Tamaiti Williams – 5
The scrum did not stabilize under his watch, and England’s physical dominance only increased.
He offered little in open play.
18 Pasilio Tosi – 5
Minimal impact.
Tosi battled in contact and did not change the direction of the tight exchanges.
19 Sam Darry – 6
Brought some energy and intent but arrived too late to influence the match’s overall shape.
A solid, but limited, contribution.
20 Wallace Sititi – 6
Showed athletic promise with a few strong carries.
His accuracy, however, dropped under pressure.
He's still developing at this level.
21 Cortez Ratima – 4
A tough cameo.
Ratima made errors that cost the All Blacks crucial field position and tempo.
A performance to learn from.
22 Anton Lienert Brown – 5
Tidy but a bit anonymous in general.
Lienert Brown defended competently but did not stamp any authority on the midfield battle.
23 Damian McKenzie – 7
Brought energy and creativity on arrival.
McKenzie threatened the line and injected spark.
Unfortunately for New Zealand, he came on too late to reshape the contest.
How To Watch Rugby Matches In The United States On FloRugby
Professional club rugby in Europe all streams on FloRugby and the FloSports app in the United States. FloRugby and FloSports also are the U.S. home to:
- United Rugby Championship
- PREM Rugby
- Top 14
- Investec Champions Cup
- EPCR Challenge Cup
- Currie Cup
- Super Rugby
- And more
FloRugby also is home to match archives and match replays.